TikTok Shop vs Amazon: Where Should Your Brand Focus in 2026? | Upside #99

Strategy
Written By Ali Shariat

TikTok Shop vs Amazon: Where Should You Focus?

TikTok Shop hit $64.3 billion in GMV in 2025, up 94% year on year, and the conversation among sellers has shifted to whether it's time to move off Amazon. But Amazon did $716 billion in net sales the same year. This episode breaks down what each platform is actually good for, and why the real question isn't which one to pick.

In this episode: the team compares Amazon and TikTok Shop by function rather than hype, and lays out a practical playbook for using both together.

Key takeaways

  • TikTok Shop's growth is real (94% GMV growth in 2025, a projected 48% in 2026) but still nowhere near Amazon's scale. 86% of customers still buy on Amazon regardless of where they first discovered a product.

  • Amazon is a conversion machine: people arrive with high purchase intent, compare 20-30 options, and buy the same or next day. What it's not good at is storytelling, discovery, or educating shoppers on an unfamiliar or expensive product.

  • TikTok covers the top of the funnel Amazon can't: awareness, education, and justifying price, through organic content, creators and affiliates, and in-platform selling via TikTok Shop.

  • The starting-point playbook: get your Amazon listings set up first to catch existing demand, since that's a fixed cost with low ongoing maintenance, then use TikTok to pour new awareness into the funnel.

  • Product type changes the calculus: novel, hard-to-explain, or premium-priced products benefit most from starting on TikTok to build justification before a shopper ever reaches Amazon.

  • TikTok has real weaknesses: no matching trust infrastructure to Amazon's (still more counterfeit and scam activity), unreliable view/impression metrics, and heavy platform-funded discounting whose long-term sustainability is unclear.

  • Going viral is not a strategy: most successful creators built consistency through volume (100+ videos before seeing traction) rather than one lucky hit, and a lot of affiliate content underperforms because it's obviously commission-driven.

Timestamps


00:00 — Why TikTok vs Amazon is the wrong question
00:44 — TikTok's GMV growth vs Amazon's scale
02:26 — TikTok's fastest-growing demographic: older adults
06:18 — What Amazon is built for: the conversion machine
08:24 — What TikTok is built for: the awareness and education layer
11:29 — The playbook: which platform to start with, and when
14:11 — When product type changes the starting point
17:31 — Where to focus first on TikTok: content, creators, affiliates
19:58 — TikTok's real weaknesses: trust, metrics, and discounting
23:58 — Why "just go viral" isn't a strategy
27:01 — Wrap-up: use both platforms for what they're actually good at

The detail

Amazon is a conversion machine, not an education platform
People land on Amazon already intending to buy. They compare a couple dozen options, lean on Amazon's trust and delivery speed, and convert same-day or next-day. What Amazon can't do well is explain an unfamiliar product or justify a price that looks high next to cheaper competitors, there's no real mechanism on-platform for that kind of storytelling.

TikTok fills the gap at the top of the funnel
TikTok is built to cover awareness and education, the part of the funnel Amazon skips. Organic content is free but requires consistent effort and gives full control over the brand narrative; creators and micro-affiliates add reach without needing a huge following, since TikTok's algorithm surfaces good content regardless of follower count. TikTok Shop itself then gives a path to convert that awareness on-platform, through store pages, search, affiliates, and live selling.

The playbook: start with Amazon, layer in TikTok
For most brands, get Amazon set up first since it's a fixed cost that captures existing demand with low ongoing maintenance, then use TikTok to add new awareness into the funnel over time. The exception is novel, hard-to-explain, or premium-priced products, those benefit from starting on TikTok to build understanding and justify the price before a shopper ever searches on Amazon.

Where TikTok still falls short
TikTok hasn't built Amazon-level trust: more counterfeit and scam activity, and none of Amazon's willingness to deactivate a listing to protect a customer. View and impression metrics are also unreliable, since very brief views count as impressions, making real engagement hard to measure. Heavy TikTok-funded discounting is helping sellers now, but its long-term sustainability is an open question. And virality itself is not a repeatable strategy, most creators who succeed do it through sheer volume of content, not luck.

Resources mentioned

Work with us

← Back all podcasts
Ali Shariat
Next

9 Lessons Every Founder Needs to Hear | Upside #98